thisweek

Gathering

The pamphleteer's table

1776 · Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

Paine gathers Franklin, Jefferson, and Henry in the year of Common Sense and argues for a republic without kings.

Common Sense has made Paine famous almost overnight, and his rooms have become a meeting place for the men pushing the colonies toward independence. Franklin, who brought him to America two years earlier, is pleased and a little astonished at his success.

Jefferson, at work on the declaration, shares Paine's view of natural rights but writes more carefully. Henry needs no persuading and talks about the coming war. Paine, who has no patience for ceremony, serves a plain supper and keeps the talk on the argument that matters: that government by hereditary right is an insult to reason, and that the colonies should be free. They eat hasty pudding, fried oysters, and johnnycake, with apple tart and spruce beer, and Paine promises the next pamphlet before the summer is out.

The table

Host: Thomas Paine

Benjamin Franklin — Paine's patron, who had encouraged him to come to America.

Thomas Jefferson — At work on the declaration and sympathetic to Paine's argument.

Patrick Henry — Already committed to independence and spoiling for the fight.

The menu

Everything you need to host this menu, sorted aisle by aisle:

The menu

9 of 27 items checked

First course

Hasty Pudding

a period dish

Claimed by Thomas Paine

Serves 4 · 2 of 5 items checked · 4 aisles

Dairy & Eggs

Pantry / Durable

  • Checked by Benjamin Franklin

Spices & Seasoning

Other

  • Checked by Thomas Paine

First course

Fried Oysters

a period dish

Claimed by Benjamin Franklin

Serves 4 · 2 of 7 items checked · 5 aisles

Side

Johnnycake

a period dish

Claimed by Thomas Jefferson

Serves 8 · 2 of 5 items checked · 4 aisles

Drink

Spruce Beer

a period dish

Claimed by Thomas Paine

Serves 12 · 1 of 4 items checked · 2 aisles

The conversation

Thomas Paine

These are the times that try men's souls. Common sense tells us plainly: a continent cannot be governed by an island.

Benjamin Franklin

And a republic must be founded on reason, or it will be founded on nothing.

Thomas Jefferson

The rights of man are not a favor from any king. They are the ground on which government stands.

Patrick Henry

Then give me liberty or give me death — but let us first agree what liberty means.

A reconstruction — imagined from the figures' own writings.

This gathering is an editorial recreation grounded in the biographies of those present; it did not necessarily take place as described.